potted_music: (Default)
Add MemoryShare This Entry
posted by [personal profile] potted_music at 03:01pm on 31/03/2012
I watched The Hunger Games! I was spoiled for most plot developments, except for the most important one, the one that really made this movie for me: namely, nobody had ever told me how meta it is. It is an action movie about the making of action movies. If you had somehow managed to miss the hype, the plot goes like this: in postapocalyptic dystopian America, each of the districts that had once rebelled against the central government and lost has to yearly provide a teenage boy and girl to fight with the kids from other districts until only one is left. The rest of the population is watching these games as the most popular reality TV. And this is the really cool part of the movie: while the kids' plight subplot is interesting and intense (and stars one of the most awesome heroines I've seen in action movies in the last couple of years), it also has the subplot about the producers of the show, and they know the demands of their genre. They know when extra explosions have to be added. They know that romance sells. Ultimately, I believe that the heroine wins not because she objects to relinquish her humanity, thus rebelling against the system, but because she *gets* how the system works, and she outwits them on their own turf, resorting to one of the most venerated tropes of our culture. And that is awesome.
Of course, it is also commentary on our fixation on the bloody parts of our history as foundational traumas, and about the role of women in such narratives (the finale was utterly heart-breaking in this respect, don't want to spoil you but the cliches she has to recreate to validate her choice, oh-), but for me, the idea that narrative competence saves the world was the most awesome part of the movie.

***

Last week, I got locked in an ancient cemetery at night and talked to an owl. No matter how awesome your week might have been, I believe you cannot quite beat that. The preface being, my friend came to Boston for a conference; trying to be an awesome tour guide, I remembered that you have the best chances at seeing coyotes and owls in the wild at sunset. Whether my friend wanted to see them or not is up to debate, but, well. The closest wilderness I know of is the Mount Auburn Cemetery, so off we went. Of course, the critters are smart enough to avoid the shrieky me, even though I rushed over rows of centuries-old graves and weather-beat marble angels in the direction of the slightest noise from the bushes, displaying the sort of behaviour that is punished in zombie movies (the dead residents of Mount Auburn Cemetery are all intellectuals and somesuch, so, even if they chose to rise, the dumb materialism of brain-seeking would probably be beyond them) (Me: "But I WANT TO see a coyote!" A long-suffering friend: "Yes, and you are walking over dead bodies to accomplish that.") But then we heard an owl hooting overhead! I tried hooting at it! Screeched, more like, since I cannot hoot. The poor bird realized that the best way to shut me up would be to hoot back at me, so we talked for a while. There was a real connection there XD XD XD

And this is how I found out that even cemeteries close for the night (and that I need to grow up, but that's beyond the point).


***

Quick recspam: Seanan McGuire's summary of her new series about ecologically conscious cryptozoologists fighting evil with the power of ballroom dances. For a week, the promise of reading two or three chapters during breakfast was the only thing that could get me out of bed in the morning. Some things in the book seemed somewhat illogical to me, but it is insanely imaginative and playful, and I enjoyed it immensely.

The Bread We Eat in Dreams by Catherynne M. Valente is an awesome short story about an exiled demon that settles close to a Protestant settlement in New England: and not just any demon, but the baker of Hell, the one who makes "the bread we eat in dreams" (and I really liked the story of her previous mythological incarnations). Of course, mayhem ensues.
Catherynne M. Valente has absolutely beautiful writing style; technically, it's not poetry, but I still end up remembering long snippets, like charms.
There are 6 comments on this entry. (Reply.)
somnolentblue: statue of a woman from the waist up (Default)
posted by [personal profile] somnolentblue at 04:18am on 02/04/2012
Hunger Games! Actually, it's really interesting; the books are tight first person POV, so the way the movie uses the ability to get out of Katniss' head to watch the gamemakers and frame the narrative was fun.
potted_music: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] potted_music at 04:23am on 02/04/2012
Oh, really? So, that whole plotline was not present in the books? Wow, it's weird to see a movie adaptation that might be richer than the source text.
somnolentblue: statue of a woman from the waist up (Default)
posted by [personal profile] somnolentblue at 04:30am on 02/04/2012
It was definitely present, and there's a lot of mediation in the book on the role of the media and the need for Katniss to construct an appealing presence to get sponsors, etc. The Hunger Games is a reality show, and Katniss and Peeta are playing a game in a reality show. Also, you see her commenting on the Gamemakers doing various things, like the fire to drive her back to the other tributes as not to lose the interest of viewers.

However, since it's a tight first person, you get her talking about it or reflecting on it, etc. You can't see them plunking things down in the same way, and you don't get the contrast of the stark Gamemakers room to the green and brown of the forest. You definitely don't get Seneca Crane's inexplicable naivete mixed with his showmanship in the same way; he's there, but you don't see him off with Snow, etc. So, the trade off of losing some fo the backstory and exposition (Collins has rather a lot of info dump exposition and backstory) is more of the external world to Katniss. More show, less tell, basically, since it doesn't have to be filtered through Katniss.
potted_music: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] potted_music at 04:40am on 02/04/2012
Aha, now I really want to read the books: I see what you did there :))) For one, the critique of violent narratives as bases of group identities sort of puts the movie in an awkward position, for it lets the viewer be both dismayed by violence and still enjoy the adrenaline rush (sure, that can be pulled off - Tarantino did that in Inglorious Basterds, afair - but not in this case, I think), whereas the mediating presence of Katniss might alleviate some of that awkwardness.
somnolentblue: statue of a woman from the waist up (Default)
posted by [personal profile] somnolentblue at 04:53am on 02/04/2012
The place you get sympathetic views of the Capital are developed through Katniss' Prep Team and Effie in the books. And they're still ridiculous and privileged and, often, unthinkingly cruel, but they're richer characters than they are in the movie and give an avenue into the Capital. However, whereas on the movie the audience becomes the Capitol audience to a degree, the Prep Team and Effie (books) are always ridiculous, even if they're sympathetic (if that makes sense), and their privilege is explicitly remarked upon by Katniss.

(Srsly, the movie lost a lot of Effie. And Haymitch, so much of Haymitch. I can understand why things were cut the way they were, and the movie gave Snow and Seneca in exchange, but still. I, umm, rambled about this a lot when I posted on it, so I'll stop now. :) )

I don't disagree with some of the critiques I've seen that the books and movie fail to sufficiently break the system they're participating in/exploiting, but I did enjoy them.
potted_music: (Default)
posted by [personal profile] potted_music at 09:00pm on 02/04/2012
Oh, sympathy for the Capital is actually good (all horrible creepy dictatorships got created in the first place because they satisfied some societal needs blah-blah-blah - so, getting some background in this case would have been cool). So is more Haymitch time. I love me some Haymitch!

Links

October

SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  1
 
2
 
3
 
4
 
5
 
6
 
7
 
8
 
9
 
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
 
14 15
 
16
 
17
 
18
 
19
 
20
 
21
 
22
 
23
 
24
 
25
 
26
 
27
 
28
 
29
 
30
 
31